Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
10" Pizza
Add Bacon And Cheese To Fries
Onion Rings 8 To An Order
Cheese Curds
About
Goodfella's Pizza Henryville
Welcome to Goodfella's Pizza Henryville, a delightful gem located at 103 Colonels Way in the heart of Henryville, Indiana. This charming eatery is more than just a place to grab a slice; it's a community hub where the aroma of fresh ingredients fills the air, and friendly faces greet you at every turn. Known for its inviting atmosphere and scrumptious fares, Goodfella's has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
One of the standout offerings at Goodfella's is their impressive breakfast buffet. Customers rave about the variety of breakfast meats, fluffy scrambled eggs, and fresh fruits, all of which create a comforting start to any day. Reviewers like Dusti C and Chloe Turner highlight how the buffet is a weekly tradition for many, drawing them back for the delicious options and the warm country diner feel. Even as the weekend crowds roll in, the efficient service and the value of the buffet make every visit worthwhile.
But it isn’t just breakfast that gets rave reviews here. The restaurant's capability to serve up hot, fresh food at reasonable prices is something diners truly appreciate. As Katarina Auer points out, the cleanliness and friendliness of the staff contribute to an enjoyable dining experience, whether you're indulging in a plate of wings or one of their delectable pasta bakes. Guests feel welcomed and taken care of, fostering a sense of community that is vital in a small town.
With a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, the team at Goodfella's has made a lasting impression on patrons like LeNola Hunter, who praised their excellent service and delightful dishes. The staff’s friendly demeanor and willingness to accommodate dietary needs exemplify why this place stands out among its peers.
As you make your way to Goodfella's Pizza Henryville, prepare to savor the experience. Whether you're coming for a hearty breakfast buffet or looking for a cozy spot to enjoy a meal with loved ones, this restaurant promises not just food but warmth and camaraderie. After all, it's not just about feeding your appetite; it’s about creating memories over well-prepared meals in a welcoming environment. So, don’t miss out on this hidden gem; it may just become your new favorite spot!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ This is definitely a small town hidden gem. The dining room is very small and seating is very tight. Other than that, no complaints! Went for the breakfast buffet and it was great! Staff was very quick and friendly!! We will definitely be back. ”
“ Want the Daily Special? Come early or call ahead, because often sell out. Clean dining room, friendly staff, & hot fresh food in a casual, modern environment. Ordered 1 lb. naked wings and two pasta bakes. I would definitely come back to try the buffet. ”
“ Delicious food! We tried some dishes we hadn’t tried before and loved everything! Excellent service! Friendly, helpful, took care of all our needs. Thank you! We’ll be back!!! ”
“ We absolutely adore this small town restaurant. We have become regulars not living far away and have built rapport with multiple staff. The food has never been an issue and the breakfast buffet is the highlight of our weekends! ”
“ third time there for the weekend breakfast buffet. i highly recommend. good home country feel. friendly efficient service. food good. some beverages included in with the buffet price. great price for the buffet. great scrambled eggs. plenty of meats, fruit and pastries. update June 2022: still a great place for weekend breakfast buffet. variety of breakfast meats and fruits. some drinks are included with the meal price. great service and food. worth a 20 minute drive. August 2022: Went again for Saturday breakfast buffet. Excellent. Country feel. Casual. Clean. variety of meats, good pastries, fresh ripe fruit with a beverage and all for 10 plus tax. A big thank you. Worth the trip. October 2023: this place can get crowded during the weekend breakfast buffet. we went today, which is Saturday morning. each time we went to the buffet line we had to wait a while. the place it still has a good country diner feel. we like that the drink is included in the price and the variety of meats, plus the gravy, fruits and sweets. pros: friendly staff. April 2024: price for weekend breakfast buffet went up to 11.50 plus tax ”
“ We absolutely love the pizza here. Today, I tried something new... the pork tenderloin sandwich. It was amazing! Two thin pieces of breaded pork tenderloin with melted mozzarella between. Give it a try, you won't be disappointed! ”
“ We usually have good service on the carry out side, but we were not impressed with tonight’s food or the service. Took 10 minutes for someone to acknowledge us when we came in to pick up our food, and by the time we got home, it was too late to call about our food. It’s cold and not very fresh. Especially the wings, they have some really hard pieces that seemed burnt. We pretty much had to pick at our food. It will be a while before I consider spending another 46 to get food here again. Edit: the owner was more than willing to make things right with us and the staff was wonderful this time. We will definitely be coming back. Thank you again. ”
“ Was passing through the state looked up great places to eat in. This was one of them. They had a quaint pizza Buffay that included a garden salad and I must say my family and I could tell that the crust was handmade to perfection. I’m so glad we stopped here. Great job! ”